
For Buyers
21 min read
What is a cross lease conversion? And, why should you look into a title conversion?
What is a cross lease title?
A cross lease property is where multiple parties own an undivided share in a piece of land. Typically, this is between two parties but can be far more in some cases. This could involve a single site with two or more dwellings. Cross leased sites also often contain flats, units, or townhouses.
The houses built on the land are ‘leased’ from the other landowner. Historically cross lease tenures are for a term of 999 years. Cross leases were originally developed in the 1960s and 1970s to avoid subdivision rule requirements, which were, at the time, complex and costly.
So, a landowner does not own their section per se; they own an undivided half share of the underlying fee simple title as tenants in common. The exclusive use areas shown on the title plan are for the ‘exclusive and sole use' by their respective owner; this is a leased area rather than absolute ownership. The other party also 'leases' it's dwelling on the land from all other owners. Any common areas on the plan are subject to joint use.
Currently, in New Zealand, there are more than 200,000 cross leased properties, with roughly half of those in Auckland.
Why should I convert a cross lease?
While for many owners, a cross lease title does not impact their day-to-day living. However, due to the ownership structure, cross leases can lead to costly disputes, defective titles, and less value when you come to sell your property.
For instance, if any alterations or additions are made to any house on a cross lease title that changes the footprint or exterior in some cases, the flats plan (Title diagram) will need to be resurveyed by a surveyor and lodged with Land Information New Zealand (LINZ); also a new lease agreement is to be drawn up by a lawyer. In some cases, a resource consent will also be required by your local council. Without this, your title is defective and could lead to lengthy delays during the sale of your property, invaliding your insurance, or having the work removed completely if written permissions have not been sought from other owners.
If changes are made without the written permission of all parties, they can force you to remove the new additions. Written approval must be sought each time any changes are made to the house or building within the cross lease. Your neighbour can refuse this and, without a lengthy legal battle, could unreasonably without their consent or say 'no' for no reason.
Some cross leases are not fit for purpose. For instance, a cross lease may grant communal rights to all owners over an area of the property, say an outdoor grassed area by a block of units, where one owner being the closest to that area may assume that is their exclusive area, where this is likely to be a common area. I own a cross lease, and my neighbour and I specifically have the right within the lease to decide on the exterior colour finish of the other house. If we think about this, I choose the exterior paint of my neighbour's property that I do not own. Cross lease titles are a complicated type of ownership that create ongoing issues, speaking from experience.
What can I do about this?
With the introduction of the Resource Management Act 1991 essentially rendered cross lease titles obsolete. Many councils allow for the conversion of cross lease titles to fee simple. Fee simple is the highest form of land ownership in New Zealand and the most common. The property market generally holds the highest value to fee simple ownership. This essentially allows you to build anything on your land unless there are registered interests on the title and keeping within your local council’s planning controls. If you decide to convert the cross lease, there is a relatively simple process. This requires resource consent from your local council. Firstly, you and all other parties must be in agreement; generally, costs are shared as there is a general value uplift for all parties.
Advantages and disadvantages
Once a conversion is complete, you will no longer require permission to alter your home. It also removes the worry of any disputes arising.
A fee simple title can be more desirable to potential buyers due to the greater degree of freedom available for the use and development of the site. The Property Institute of New Zealand advises that converting a cross lease title into a fee simple ownership significantly increases the value and saleability of a property. Cross lease properties are estimated to be worth 7-18% less due to the ownership compared to fee simple.
However, those in cross lease tenures may appreciate the power they have in being able to prevent their neighbour from undertaking alterations that may impact on them. Also, the other upside of cross lease properties is they are generally cheaper than similar fee simple titles.
What is involved in converting a cross lease?
If you and your neighbour(s) decide that you both wish to convert your cross lease title, that is the first and most crucial step. Without all parties agreeing, the conversion cannot take place. The first step is always talking to the other owners. During this discussion, it is best to determine whether they would be interested in undertaking a conversion, setting out a timeframe, and agreeing to costs. Ultimately all parties are likely to benefit from the conversion of the title to fee simple, and it may be appropriate to share expenses equally.
Who can help me with this process?
A planner is best placed to negotiate with the Council on your behalf to achieve a cost-effective and timely outcome. As resource consent is required from your local council, a planner can prepare this application on your behalf. Most importantly, they can ensure there are no resource consent conditions that require you or your neighbour to undertake costly service upgrades unless essential that you would otherwise need if you were subdividing a site.
To complete a cross lease conversion, you will require a project team consisting of a planner, surveyor, engineer, and lawyer. Code Planning generally advises their clients that the cost for the total project will be roughly $20,000. However, when split with other owners, this can be a simple and effective way of increasing your property value quickly.
A planner will be experienced in the process and deal with councils on a daily basis. Planners will achieve the best result for clients by understanding the consent process. This is less likely through the use of third-party companies. We advise clients to engage a CCTV company early with an engineer to understand the current state of services, such as stormwater, wastewater, and vehicle access. By completing a service review, you will be aware of all possible costs, leading to an overall cheaper process. Using an experienced project team that a planner can assemble on your behalf will keep costs down and achieve a timely result. Once services are reviewed, the planner will prepare a resource consent application.
We would recommend using your own solicitor. The solicitor can represent both parties which can save on cost and time. Alternatively, each party may have their own solicitor. Using your own solicitor with which you already have a relationship is the best place to start. However, the solicitor will need experience in land conveyance and cross lease conversion.
The Council will review the existing services to both properties. If these are in good working order, no further physical work is required. If the services are damaged, these may need to be repaired, such as a cracked stormwater or wastewater pipe. That section of pipe will need to be repaired and signed off for the cross lease to be signed off by the Council. As all the services have CCTV taken by a technician, an engineer can identify if there are any issues early in the process. Once consent is granted, it is on to the final steps in the process.
From this point, the surveyor and lawyer will prepare the documentation submitted to Land Information New Zealand (LINZ). This may also require updating your current mortgage on your title and home insurance. Then, LINZ will issue the new fee simple titles, and the conversion process will be completed.
Below is a summary of the various steps that we will need to complete as part of the process.
Pre-Consent
- CCTV footage of all services for all properties
- Review of CCTV footage by an engineer
Consent Stage
- Surveyor attends site and marks out properties and services - Provides scheme plan for your review prior to lodging resource consent with Council
- Engineering Report - review of all services for both properties as well as driveways or access
- Planning Report
- Application for Resource Consent is made to Council
Post-Consent
- Surveyor attends site again and confirms final position of boundaries - Shall draft new title plan, which will be submitted to Council/LINZ
- Surveyor and Engineer applies for sign off from Council for s223/224 (Surveying and Engineering Approval)
- Surveyor and solicitor apply to LINZ for new titles for each property
- Solicitor will update all interest on the property, such as any mortgage or easement
Key tips when converting a cross lease property
- Firstly, talk to your neighbour about the benefits of cross lease conversions and maintain a healthy relationship.
- Contact a planner; the planner manages the resource consent process for you and can identify potential issues and risks. In some cases, they can act for both parties and advise both accordingly.
- Avoid companies that will use an expansive project manager and send the work out separately to various other companies. These generally result in poor outcomes for clients.
- Allow sufficient time for the cross lease conversion to be completed. Particularly if you are converting before a property sale. We generally advise clients that this can take six months.
- Once the conversion is complete, enjoy your home and that deck extension or new bedroom without worry.
This article was prepared by George McMahon of Code Planning. Code Planning is a planning and resource management consultancy based on Auckland’s North Shore. Code Planning specialises in cross lease conversion, resource consent applications, subdivision, and land development.
If you own a cross lease property and are interested in investigating the conversion to a fee simple title, you can contact the team at Code Planning. They can assist with the process along with the preparation of the consent application. You can contact mills@codeplanning.co.nz or 0210711480 (George) or 0211106525 (Haden).
