
For Buyers
13 min read
What To Do When You’ve Hired A Bad Contractor
Working on a property development project usually requires investing a lot of time, money, and energy. To make sure it stays as stress-free as possible, you should always try to work with great people who you can fully trust. However, even the most experienced developers run into difficult tradies from time to time. In this article, we have some tips on what to do when you realise you’ve hired a bad contractor, and how to resolve the situation as smoothly as possible.
So what does a bad building contractor look like? There are many red flags you may have noticed, such as:
Unfortunately, there often isn’t much you can do if you’ve hired a bad contractor. Unless they’re seriously and persistently breaching the contract, you likely need to see the project through to the end. If you do cancel the contract, then you need to have a good enough reason and give the contractor a chance to rectify the situation.
Check the contract for information about the dispute resolution process. The first step is usually sending a written notice to let them know that you’re not happy. Outline what they should do to get things back on track, and include a date that indicates when things need to be fixed by.
If you’ve tried to communicate but the contractor continues to break the terms of the contract, then you can often cancel the contract. Just be careful - an attempt to terminate when you’re not entitled to do so can be interpreted as a breach of contract on your part! Before taking action, you should definitely consult with your lawyer.
If your attempts to resolve the situation just haven’t been working out, then it may be time to formally end the relationship. This can be pretty awkward, but you’ll feel so much better once you’ve done it and are free to bring in a new contractor who you can actually trust.
It’s never a good idea to fire someone when you’re all riled up. Choose a quiet time to sit down and tell them that you’re looking to end the relationship. Let them know that you’d really appreciate their cooperation as you shift over to a new team. If they’ve got building materials on the way or a large team of subcontractors, they’re likely to have questions about the logistics of the changeover, so give them a chance to discuss these with you.
Even if things end fairly amicably, you should keep as much evidence as you can. It’s best to discuss the termination in person, but make sure you send a written notice too. Keep all evidence of breached contract terms, attempts at dispute resolution, and other communications you’ve had. Hopefully, the situation will never end up in court, but if it does, you want to have plenty of evidence to support you.
If you’ve gotten rid of a terrible building contractor, you probably just want to put the situation behind you. That’s often the best course of action, but you may want (or need) to go a step further. Here’s what you can do.
The Disputes Tribunal allows New Zealanders to resolve claims without having to go through the court process. They deal with claims of up to $30,000, and a trained referee will hear your case. They can make an order, which is legally binding and enforced by the courts.
However, if your claim is for more than $30,000, then you might decide to take your case to the District Court. If you decide to go down this route, you should definitely seek legal advice before getting started, as it can be a complex and costly process.
Mediation is often preferable to taking the matter to court, as it’s much cheaper, faster, and simpler. A trained mediator will sit down with both parties and you’ll try to come to a solution together. You can access mediation through organisations such as the Resolution Institute.
If the project cost more than $30,000 (including GST) or you asked for the builder to give you a disclosure statement, standard checklist, or written contract and they failed to provide this, you can lodge a complaint with MBIE. They’ll assess the situation and may issue a $500 fine.
You should also lodge a complaint with MBIE or your local council if your builder doesn’t have the license they need to carry out the work that they did for you. They will investigate, and may prosecute them.
Your building contractor might be a member of a professional organisation, such as the New Zealand Certified Builders Association. Each organisation has its own complaints process, but you could consider letting them know about your experience.
If your contractor did something really dangerous or has made you feel unsafe, you might consider contacting law enforcement. For instance, if they assaulted or threatened you, you could talk to the police about this.
Getting things in order after you’ve hired a bad contractor can be stressful, but try to stay calm, seek advice from your lawyer, and take things one step at a time. For more property development tips, check out these posts:
What The New Housing Density Rules Mean For Property Developers
How To Choose A Builder For Your Property Development Project
Signs you’ve hired a bad contractor
So what does a bad building contractor look like? There are many red flags you may have noticed, such as:
- Their work is bad. Obviously, your builder’s main job is to build. If their workmanship is poor, this is a big problem that needs to be addressed.
- They don’t communicate well. It can be really tough if they’re late to meetings, disorganised, avoiding questions, and are generally hard to deal with. This person is meant to stay on top of the nuts and bolts side of your property development project, so good communication is key.
- They leave a mess. Take a look at the worksite. Is there rubbish lying around? Are walkways clear? A messy worksite is a safety hazard, and any decent builder will always ensure that they’re keeping things tidy and safe.
- They’re overly casual. Brushing aside things like permits, insurance, protective equipment, or licensing is a major red flag. All builders need to take regulations seriously.
- Their conduct is unprofessional. It’s a serious issue if they’re rude, or doing things like drinking on the job or being careless with your property.
- They rush the job. If the job gets delayed, either on your end or theirs, they should be understanding and patient about it. The job being done right is always more important than the job being done quickly.
- It’s taking way too long. On the other hand, if they never seem to be working and the project is dragging on and getting behind schedule, it can be very frustrating.
Communicate your concerns
Unfortunately, there often isn’t much you can do if you’ve hired a bad contractor. Unless they’re seriously and persistently breaching the contract, you likely need to see the project through to the end. If you do cancel the contract, then you need to have a good enough reason and give the contractor a chance to rectify the situation.
Check the contract for information about the dispute resolution process. The first step is usually sending a written notice to let them know that you’re not happy. Outline what they should do to get things back on track, and include a date that indicates when things need to be fixed by.
If you’ve tried to communicate but the contractor continues to break the terms of the contract, then you can often cancel the contract. Just be careful - an attempt to terminate when you’re not entitled to do so can be interpreted as a breach of contract on your part! Before taking action, you should definitely consult with your lawyer.
How to fire a builder (with minimal conflict)
If your attempts to resolve the situation just haven’t been working out, then it may be time to formally end the relationship. This can be pretty awkward, but you’ll feel so much better once you’ve done it and are free to bring in a new contractor who you can actually trust.
Try to stay on good terms
It’s never a good idea to fire someone when you’re all riled up. Choose a quiet time to sit down and tell them that you’re looking to end the relationship. Let them know that you’d really appreciate their cooperation as you shift over to a new team. If they’ve got building materials on the way or a large team of subcontractors, they’re likely to have questions about the logistics of the changeover, so give them a chance to discuss these with you.
Keep all documentation
Even if things end fairly amicably, you should keep as much evidence as you can. It’s best to discuss the termination in person, but make sure you send a written notice too. Keep all evidence of breached contract terms, attempts at dispute resolution, and other communications you’ve had. Hopefully, the situation will never end up in court, but if it does, you want to have plenty of evidence to support you.
When to take further action
If you’ve gotten rid of a terrible building contractor, you probably just want to put the situation behind you. That’s often the best course of action, but you may want (or need) to go a step further. Here’s what you can do.
Take the case to the Disputes Tribunal or District Court
The Disputes Tribunal allows New Zealanders to resolve claims without having to go through the court process. They deal with claims of up to $30,000, and a trained referee will hear your case. They can make an order, which is legally binding and enforced by the courts.
However, if your claim is for more than $30,000, then you might decide to take your case to the District Court. If you decide to go down this route, you should definitely seek legal advice before getting started, as it can be a complex and costly process.
Seek mediation
Mediation is often preferable to taking the matter to court, as it’s much cheaper, faster, and simpler. A trained mediator will sit down with both parties and you’ll try to come to a solution together. You can access mediation through organisations such as the Resolution Institute.
Lodge a complaint with the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment
If the project cost more than $30,000 (including GST) or you asked for the builder to give you a disclosure statement, standard checklist, or written contract and they failed to provide this, you can lodge a complaint with MBIE. They’ll assess the situation and may issue a $500 fine.
You should also lodge a complaint with MBIE or your local council if your builder doesn’t have the license they need to carry out the work that they did for you. They will investigate, and may prosecute them.
Complain to their professional body
Your building contractor might be a member of a professional organisation, such as the New Zealand Certified Builders Association. Each organisation has its own complaints process, but you could consider letting them know about your experience.
Call the police
If your contractor did something really dangerous or has made you feel unsafe, you might consider contacting law enforcement. For instance, if they assaulted or threatened you, you could talk to the police about this.
Getting things in order after you’ve hired a bad contractor can be stressful, but try to stay calm, seek advice from your lawyer, and take things one step at a time. For more property development tips, check out these posts:
What The New Housing Density Rules Mean For Property Developers
How To Choose A Builder For Your Property Development Project