banner
For Buyers
12 min read

How To Choose The Right Tenants For Your Rental Property 

If you’ve been a landlord for a while, you already know how valuable a great tenant is. These are renters who are easy to communicate with, always pay on time, and respect your property. Unfortunately, knowing exactly how to choose the right tenants for your rental property is often more complex than you might think. Although there’s no totally foolproof method, in this article we have five solid tips for choosing the tenants of your dreams. 

 

 

Why make sure you choose great tenants?


If you think that any tenant who simply pays their rent is good enough for you, think again. By choosing high quality tenants, you’ll: 

 

  • Minimise the risk of damage to your home. While normal wear and tear is to be expected, you want to rest assured that your tenants aren’t likely to throw huge parties, smash windows, and make a mess. This type of damage is often expensive to fix, and could decrease your rent returns in the future.  

  • Make potential insurance claims easier for yourself. If a tenant causes serious damage and their bond isn’t enough to cover it, your landlord’s insurance policy should be able to cover a lot of the cost. However, your insurer may require you to give evidence about how you selected the tenants, so you need to prove you did your due diligence. 

  • Avoid the difficult process of ending a tenancy early. If you end up on bad terms with your tenants, ending the lease can be time-consuming and stressful. Remember, it takes just 10 minutes to get tenants into the property, but it takes weeks to get them out. 


 

 

How to choose the right tenants for your rental property 


Present the property well 


If your property is dirty, damp, and poorly maintained, you can’t really be surprised when it doesn’t attract good tenants. Great renters, such as professionals or families, will be looking for a high quality property that they can feel comfortable living in. 

 

Before hosting a viewing, make sure that you’re catering to the needs of your desired demographic. Make sure it’s clean and tidy, do a few key renovations, and make sure all fittings and electrics are in good working order. You’ll be amazed at how such quick fixes will alter the types of people showing up to your viewings. 

 

 

Have a friendly chat with potential tenants 


Yes, employment and rental history checks are important, but getting to know your tenants is a great first step towards having a healthy relationship with them. At viewings, be friendly and open.   

Talk to potential tenants about their jobs, hobbies, and what they’re looking for in a property. You may be surprised, in good and bad ways, at the answers you get. If your application process comes down to two potential tenants who each have great references, the vibe you got off them at the viewing might just tip you in the right direction. 

 

 

Check their references 


If your potential tenants have been able to provide proof of income, then it’s time to move onto checking their references. This is a great way to get a firsthand account of what the tenant is like. Usually, they’ll provide the details of two referees on the application form. This could be a friend, employer, or anyone else who knows them well. Usually, at least one referee will be a current or previous landlord.  

When you ring up their referee, you can ask a few questions to get an idea of their behaviour. For a character reference, you can ask how they know the applicant and general questions about their personality. If the referee is a past landlord, you can be a little more specific. Ask if they paid rent on time, kept the place tidy, and if they were easy to communicate with. 

 

 

Run a few extra background checks 


Many landlords will simply make sure the tenant is employed and has a good reference or two. If you don’t have many people interested in the property and you get a good vibe from these applicants, then that may be enough. However, if you’ve narrowed it down to a few good options and want to go that extra mile to choose the right tenants, you could check: 

 

  • The Tenancy Tribunal database. Every year, the Tenancy Tribunal hears around 20,000 disputes between landlords and tenants. The decisions they make are publicly available on the Tenancy Tribunal Orders database. A quick search will let you know if they’ve been involved in a dispute in the past, and the outcome of the case. 

  • The applicant’s credit score. If you’re not totally confident in the applicant’s ability to pay the rent, this can give a good idea of any past debt, payment defaults, and more. Just make sure that they’ve given you consent to check their credit history - it’s a standard part of a New Zealand tenancy application. 

  • Social media. A quick look over of an applicant’s Facebook or Instagram could give a good insight into their personality. Just remember not to judge too harshly: not everything posted on social media is accurate! 


 

While these checks can be valuable for putting your mind at ease about a potential tenant, remember that you can’t totally rely on them. A tenant might have been to the Tenancy Tribunal because of a truly terrible landlord (be sure to check the outcome of the hearing), or have little credit information available because they’ve lived overseas. And of course, what they post on Instagram is unlikely to fully represent the type of tenant they would be. 

 

 

Go with your gut 


Don’t ignore your intuition. Avoid selecting an applicant who you don’t feel entirely comfortable with. It’s not worth feeling stressed throughout the whole duration of the tenancy. If you’re not satisfied with any of the applications, simply hold a new viewing and assess the new applicants until you find one you like.  

If you don’t have time to be methodical, but still want to make sure you rent to great tenants, consider working with a property manager. These professionals usually work at real estate agencies, and are experienced in choosing the best possible renters for your property. 

 

If you’re thinking about taking the plunge into real estate investing, these articles could help you to make sure you’re on the right track: 

The Best Cities To Buy An Investment Property In New Zealand  

Top property tech tools for modern landlords 

 

 

 

Share post

Stay up to date

withRelab°

by signing up

to our newsletter.