
For Buyers
13 min read
Which is the better choice for an investment property - building new or buying an established home?
There are plenty of decisions to make when you're looking to invest in property. And perhaps one of the biggest ones is whether you should build a brand new home or purchase an existing house straight from the local real estate listings.
Unfortunately, there's no straight answer. But, by making a few comparisons (and having a deeper understanding of your own circumstances), you should be able to come to the fitting conclusion that will work best for you.
Here’s what to think about before embarking on your next property investment.
New build homes will always be a popular choice for renters, which will ensure you can always get the right tenants for your property.
You can also look to directly cater to the market by understanding what kind of homes are in demand - want do they want and what will keep them here? Having the most attractive house available for rent could help lock the perfect tenant in for the long term, minimising any stress and headaches for you.
A brand new home should be extremely low maintenance - and anything that happens in the first few years is typically covered by the building firm's guarantee. This means you can simply sit back and let the tenants enjoy the home without worrying about appliances, heating, or plumbing that needs fixing or replacing.
There are a number of financial benefits that come from building new:
In many New Zealand's popular towns, cities, and suburbs - vacant land to build on is hard to come by, and large developments of new builds/subdivisions are usually in outlying areas away from the central business districts. Because retail, amenities, schools, and transport links can take a few years to catch up, there is always the possibility that your new build may not realise its true rental yield for a period of time.
The reason building a new house isn’t the number one choice of every homeowner is because the process can be quite drawn out.
From liaising with building companies to designers, contractors, and the local council - it can be months before foundations even go down. Meanwhile, you will have a deposit to pay and instalments to be made, all without rental returns to offset your investment - not to mention it being a lot more work from your side of things, and dealing with the typical delays that occur on-site.
This is something that can vary depending on your location and the construction market in general. At the time of posting this blog (April 2022), building materials are at an all-time high, significantly pushing up the cost of new builds.
Due to a variety of factors, including the supply chain and Covid-19 interruptions, this may mean that building a new investment property will be more expensive than buying an established home.
Choosing the right location for your investment property is key.
And while this includes things such as proximity to transport links, schools, recreational facilities, and retail amenities, it's also about considering suburbs or towns where rental properties are in demand.
So if you're buying an existing home, you have the advantage of being able to select from several listings, usually in the exact location that will provide you a solid ROI.
From a bit of a fixer-upper to a total renovator, plenty of exciting opportunities is available to those buying an existing property to realise a substantial value increase. Older homes are also usually built on larger sections than ones in newer subdivisions, so subdivision could be possible.
When you build new, what you get is it. But who knows what you could achieve if the right property came onto the market, where you can possibly add value.
As soon as the vendors have moved out, you can move tenants in (provided there is no property maintenance to undertake). So no waiting for the long building process - allowing you to have an immediate return and start working on building that cash flow.
The Government’s healthy home standards first came into law in July 2019, requiring compliance by property investors for a number of specific and minimum standards for heating, insulation, ventilation, moisture, drainage, and draught stopping.
If you’re buying an existing home to rent out, you will have to ensure it meets all of these requirements before tenants can occupy the property. Meeting these standards could require a significant financial outlay.
When you compare similar properties (in terms of size/bedrooms and location), new builds will usually give you a better rental yield than an existing property because you can charge higher rent in relation to their value/demand.
Along with meeting the Healthy Home Standards, maintenance costs are higher with older homes. Even if you ensure a close inspection before you buy the property, you can never know whether the heating source is going to need repairing due to a malfunction or that the hot water cylinder will have to be replaced in six months.
When buying an existing property, if you sell it within ten years of purchase, you may have to pay tax on any gain made by the sale. This could mean holding onto an investment property for longer than what you initially planned to do or putting you at a disadvantage if you have to sell for any reason out of your control.
Required deposits are also higher for an existing home, and mortgage rates can also be more than for a new build. And from the 1st of October 2021, interest expenses are not able to be offset against the rental income.
Hopefully, the above points have given you greater clarity on which option to take when buying your next investment property. And for more help on your investment journey, check out these two recent blogs:
9 Features To Look For In A Profitable Rental Property
How To Buy Your First Rental Property: A Step By Step Guide
Unfortunately, there's no straight answer. But, by making a few comparisons (and having a deeper understanding of your own circumstances), you should be able to come to the fitting conclusion that will work best for you.
Here’s what to think about before embarking on your next property investment.
Advantages of building new
Meet market demand
New build homes will always be a popular choice for renters, which will ensure you can always get the right tenants for your property.
You can also look to directly cater to the market by understanding what kind of homes are in demand - want do they want and what will keep them here? Having the most attractive house available for rent could help lock the perfect tenant in for the long term, minimising any stress and headaches for you.
Low maintenance
A brand new home should be extremely low maintenance - and anything that happens in the first few years is typically covered by the building firm's guarantee. This means you can simply sit back and let the tenants enjoy the home without worrying about appliances, heating, or plumbing that needs fixing or replacing.
Financial advantages
There are a number of financial benefits that come from building new:
- Traditionally, a lower deposit is required, and your borrowing power is higher.
- A new home allows you to realise equity faster, as once it is built, its value will likely increase (particularly in terms of capital gains).
- The Bright Line rule is a shorter time period for new builds than it is for an existing property, lessening the chance of you having to pay tax on any gain from the sale.
Disadvantages of building new
Location
In many New Zealand's popular towns, cities, and suburbs - vacant land to build on is hard to come by, and large developments of new builds/subdivisions are usually in outlying areas away from the central business districts. Because retail, amenities, schools, and transport links can take a few years to catch up, there is always the possibility that your new build may not realise its true rental yield for a period of time.
Realising ROI (return on investment)
The reason building a new house isn’t the number one choice of every homeowner is because the process can be quite drawn out.
From liaising with building companies to designers, contractors, and the local council - it can be months before foundations even go down. Meanwhile, you will have a deposit to pay and instalments to be made, all without rental returns to offset your investment - not to mention it being a lot more work from your side of things, and dealing with the typical delays that occur on-site.
Could be expensive
This is something that can vary depending on your location and the construction market in general. At the time of posting this blog (April 2022), building materials are at an all-time high, significantly pushing up the cost of new builds.
Due to a variety of factors, including the supply chain and Covid-19 interruptions, this may mean that building a new investment property will be more expensive than buying an established home.
Advantages of buying an established property
Location
Choosing the right location for your investment property is key.
And while this includes things such as proximity to transport links, schools, recreational facilities, and retail amenities, it's also about considering suburbs or towns where rental properties are in demand.
So if you're buying an existing home, you have the advantage of being able to select from several listings, usually in the exact location that will provide you a solid ROI.
Adding value
From a bit of a fixer-upper to a total renovator, plenty of exciting opportunities is available to those buying an existing property to realise a substantial value increase. Older homes are also usually built on larger sections than ones in newer subdivisions, so subdivision could be possible.
When you build new, what you get is it. But who knows what you could achieve if the right property came onto the market, where you can possibly add value.
Immediate tenancy
As soon as the vendors have moved out, you can move tenants in (provided there is no property maintenance to undertake). So no waiting for the long building process - allowing you to have an immediate return and start working on building that cash flow.
Disadvantages of buying an established property
Healthy Home Standards
The Government’s healthy home standards first came into law in July 2019, requiring compliance by property investors for a number of specific and minimum standards for heating, insulation, ventilation, moisture, drainage, and draught stopping.
If you’re buying an existing home to rent out, you will have to ensure it meets all of these requirements before tenants can occupy the property. Meeting these standards could require a significant financial outlay.
Lower rental yield
When you compare similar properties (in terms of size/bedrooms and location), new builds will usually give you a better rental yield than an existing property because you can charge higher rent in relation to their value/demand.
Hidden costs
Along with meeting the Healthy Home Standards, maintenance costs are higher with older homes. Even if you ensure a close inspection before you buy the property, you can never know whether the heating source is going to need repairing due to a malfunction or that the hot water cylinder will have to be replaced in six months.
More financial compliance
When buying an existing property, if you sell it within ten years of purchase, you may have to pay tax on any gain made by the sale. This could mean holding onto an investment property for longer than what you initially planned to do or putting you at a disadvantage if you have to sell for any reason out of your control.
Required deposits are also higher for an existing home, and mortgage rates can also be more than for a new build. And from the 1st of October 2021, interest expenses are not able to be offset against the rental income.
Hopefully, the above points have given you greater clarity on which option to take when buying your next investment property. And for more help on your investment journey, check out these two recent blogs:
9 Features To Look For In A Profitable Rental Property
How To Buy Your First Rental Property: A Step By Step Guide